Twitter Says Musk Signed Deal Without Asking for More Information

Twitter revealed its account on Tuesday of its deal negotiations with Elon Musk, displaying he opted out of asking the questions concerning the social media firm’s enterprise he has now cited in declaring the $44 billion (roughly Rs. 3,40,923 crore) acquisition is “on maintain.”

The account, revealed in Twitter’s proxy assertion that outlines what shareholders must know to vote on the deal, paints an image of Musk in a rush to clinch a cope with his “greatest and closing” supply.

Musk negotiated the Twitter deal over the weekend of April 23 and April 24 with out finishing up any due diligence, the proxy assertion reveals.

Since signing the deal on April 25, Musk has questioned the accuracy of Twitter’s public filings about spam accounts representing lower than 5 p.c of its person base, claiming they have to be no less than 20 p.c. This is regardless of Twitter stating in its filings that the numbers may very well be larger than it estimates.

Independent researchers have projected that 9 p.c to fifteen p.c of the thousands and thousands of Twitter profiles are bots.

Musk tweeted on Tuesday that Twitter Chief Executive Parag Agrawal has refused to point out proof for his firm’s estimate and that the deal can’t transfer ahead till he does. Twitter’s proxy assertion reveals that within the run-up to the deal Musk made no effort to get details about the difficulty.

“Mr. Musk didn’t ask to enter right into a confidentiality settlement or search from Twitter any personal information relating to Twitter,” Twitter mentioned in its proxy assertion.

The proxy assertion makes no point out of threats Musk has tweeted about not going forward with the deal if he doesn’t resolve what number of spam accounts are on the platform.

Twitter buyers appeared satisfied {that a} deal on the agreed worth was now out of the query. Twitter shares had been buying and selling round $37.55 (roughly Rs. 2,900) on Tuesday afternoon, a reduction of greater than 30 p.c to the $54.20 (roughly Rs. 4,200) per share deal worth.

Musk prompt for the primary time on Monday at a convention in Miami that the deal may very well be carried out at a cheaper price, with out specifying what that may very well be. He has but to tell Twitter that he desires to renegotiate the deal.

Legal consultants have mentioned Musk would doubtless lose in courtroom if he tried to stroll away from a deal. But they are saying that any litigation would doubtless be protracted and forged uncertainty over Twitter’s enterprise. Even firms which have prevailed in courtroom over their acquirers have ended up negotiating monetary settlements.

Musk is contractually obligated to pay a $1 billion (roughly Rs. 7,750 crore) break-up payment if he doesn’t full the deal, however Twitter can sue for “particular efficiency” to pressure Musk to finish a deal and acquire a settlement from him in consequence.

Ann Lipton, a professor at Tulane University Law School, mentioned the truth that Musk had not requested Twitter for data earlier than signing the deal meant he would now have to point out that the corporate’s public filings had been improper and posed vital long-term monetary points — a excessive authorized bar.

“Twitter has lengthy mentioned ‘that is our estimate of spam however we could be improper.’ So it is not clear that they mentioned something false,” Lipton mentioned.


Twitter mentioned on Tuesday it remained dedicated to the deal on the agreed worth and anticipated it to be accomplished in 2022.

The San Francisco-based firm mentioned in its proxy assertion that Musk expressed his curiosity in becoming a member of its board or taking it personal on March 26. This would point out that Musk mischaracterised his stake of greater than 9 p.c in Twitter as passive when he revealed it in a regulatory submitting on April 4. He subsequently clarified it was an energetic stake.

Representatives of Musk didn’t reply to requests for remark.

Musk additionally advised Twitter that he contemplated beginning a competitor, in response to the proxy assertion.

Twitter’s CEO, Agrawal, is entitled to a $60.2 million (roughly Rs. 466 crore) golden parachute if the deal closes, whereas the corporate’s chief monetary officer, Ned Segal, would get $46.4 (roughly Rs. 360 crore) million, the proxy reveals. Twitter’s prime lawyer, Vijaya Gadde, could be paid $30 million (roughly  Rs. 232 crore).

Goldman Sachs Group Inc stands to be paid $65 million (roughly Rs. 503 crore) for advising Twitter as soon as the deal is accomplished, having already been paid $15 million (roughly Rs. 116 crore), the proxy assertion reveals.

Another Twitter adviser, JPMorgan Chase & Co, stands to be paid $48 million (roughly Rs. 372 crore) as soon as the deal closes, having already made $5 million (roughly Rs. 39 crore) for its equity opinion to the corporate.

Leave a Comment